Three Guys

Experience authentic Italian dining at Three Guys Italian Restaurant in Kenilworth, NJ. Enjoy classic dishes like Veal Parmigiana, Eggplant Parm, Chicken Marsala, and Penne Vodka in a friendly, family atmosphere. Cash only. Call +1 908-272-2553 for reservations.

Welcome to Three Guys

Experience the finest dining

Three Guys
Three Guys
Three Guys
Three Guys

Step into Three Guys, the hidden gem of Kenilworth, New Jersey. This charming Italian restaurant occupies a cozy spot on 20th Street, serving up home-cooked meals since its inception. Known for its warm ambiance and friendly service, it’s a favorite for families and locals seeking authentic Italian flavors. Visitors quickly fall in love with the delicious aroma wafting from the kitchen as they peruse the menu filled with comforting classics.

By using cash only, Three Guys ensures smooth and quick transactions, allowing patrons to focus on what really matters: the food. Few establishments possess the charm and character that Three Guys has cultivated, making it a vibrant part of the community.

Three Guys boasts an impressive range of features that cater to every Italian food enthusiast. Family-style dining creates an inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal place for gatherings. Dishes like Veal Parmigiana and Chicken Marsala shine on the menu, crafted with fresh ingredients that guarantee incredible taste. And for those who love to sip while they savor, the restaurant is BYOB, allowing you to bring your favorite bottle to complement your meal.

An open kitchen layout adds to the lively feel, giving diners a glimpse of the culinary magic happening behind the scenes.

The decor reflects a casual, warm Italian vibe with rustic touches that make for a laid-back dining experience. Lastly, pricing here is incredibly reasonable, making it accessible for everyone looking for quality Italian fare without breaking the bank.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

19 N 20th St, Kenilworth, NJ 07033, United States

Phone

+1 908-272-2553

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Three Guys
Three Guys
Three Guys
Three Guys

Three Guys Italian Restaurant represents the heart and soul of Kenilworth’s local dining scene. With a rich history dating back several years, this establishment has become synonymous with authentic Italian cuisine. Family-owned and operated, Three Guys prides itself on serving recipes passed down through generations, each bite echoing tradition and love.

The menu features a blend of both classic and contemporary dishes. Favorites such as Eggplant Parm, Penne Vodka, and Chicken Cutlet are crafted with care and attention to detail. Every plate served embodies the essence of Italian cooking—simple, fresh, and fulfilling. The commitment to quality ingredients ensures that every meal is not only satisfying but also memorable. The restaurant has curiously managed to maintain a family-friendly environment, where laughter and good times fill the air.

Regular diners appreciate the restaurant’s cash-only policy, which maintains a no-fuss dining experience. From regular lunch crowds to bustling Saturday evenings, the restaurant often reaches full capacity during peak hours, especially at dinner. On weekends, especially Saturdays, the atmosphere is lively, with patrons sharing plates and stories, united by the joy of good food. For those wary of crowds, visiting during lunch hours or early dinner times proves to be the best strategy to enjoy the fantastic offerings without the hustle and bustle.

Three Guys goes beyond providing meals; it fosters a sense of community. Local events and gatherings often see participation from this establishment, strengthening its ties to the neighborhoods it serves. Whether it's a casual lunch after a long workday or a festive family dinner, Three Guys is the go-to spot that effortlessly combines great food with a welcoming atmosphere.

Three Guys

The exterior of Three Guys reflects its charming persona. Nestled on a bustling street in Kenilworth, the restaurant is easy to spot, with inviting signage and a cozy facade that beckons diners inside. The outdoor seating area, while modest, captures the casual Italian vibe and offers a pleasant spot for al fresco dining during warm weather. The ambiance is ever so lively, often filled with the sounds of laughter and clinking glasses. Visitors note the delightful environment, a splendid blend of comfort and vibrancy that characterizes an authentic Italian eatery.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday2-8:30 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Nestled away on a quiet street, this unassuming Italian restaurant delivers an unforgettable dining experience. Despite its modest appearance, the food here is exceptional. We shared a variety of dishes, each bursting with flavor and authenticity. The service was impeccable, adding to the overall enjoyment. Don't miss the fresh hot bread and antipasto salad. Portions were generous, allowing us to bring some home for later. For a genuine taste of Italy, this hidden gem is a must-visit. **Side Note:** It's worth mentioning that this charming establishment operates on a cash-only basis, with no option for credit card payments. However, fear not if you find yourself short on cash, as they conveniently provide an ATM machine onsite for your convenience.

C
Christopher B.

We stopped in for lunch on our way into NY. Absolutely fantastic pizza! Perfectly crispy crust and overall excellent. While we were there, they were preparing trays of food for a big event. If you are looking for authentic and delicious Italian food, Three Guys From Italy is your place to go!

M
Michael K.

Great spot for a good Itlian meal Had the veal & eggplant parmigiana ,and the pizza is great too

J
Jeffrey G.

Went for lunch but could not pass up the veal parm. Nick, the owner, treated.us like gold. We ate.outside.and it felt like we stepped back in time. We moved away from this area about 15 years ago but the food is as good as ever. Wife has the eggplant parm and she was as happy has i was.

S
Samuel M.

Excellent and authentic Italian spot in Kenilworth, NJ Visiting from Chicago, this is the real deal. Mussels and Escarole and beans were superb!!

L
Lacey M.

Been coming here since I was a child ! Off the boat and always good!! The best bread ever too. Thanks for all the birthday dinners and memories !

M
Mel B.